Skip to content

Compare models

GPT-6.1 Sol vs Claude Opus 5

By Ofrai Editorial (Model Testing Team)

These two cost about the same, so price will not decide it, and they are close enough in capability that a single prompt will not decide it either. What separates them is what happens once a task stops being one question and becomes a session. GPT-6.1 Sol is built to keep executing a long procedure without losing the thread. Claude Opus 5 is built to keep judging a long problem without accepting the first framing. Pick by the shape of the work.

Open GPT-6.1 Sol

Chat and video use credits from your Ofrai balance.

The axis is not price, it is what happens at step thirty

In Ofrai Text Studio these two cost about the same, so treating the comparison as a cost question is the fastest route to a wrong answer. The difference that survives a real project is behavioural, and it appears only once a task stops being a single question. Sol is shaped to keep executing: long agentic runs, instruction chains that accumulate, tool-call sequences where step twelve depends on step eleven having landed.

Opus 5 is shaped to keep judging: requirements that contradict each other, long material, and a conclusion someone acts on without a second reading. One is the worker you brief, one is the reviewer you consult. Across a session you feel the difference in every message after the tenth.

The decision rule that follows from this is narrow and testable: if the task can be written as an ordered list of steps that must all happen, you are in Sol's territory, and if it cannot, because what you actually have is a stack of considerations you do not yet know how to weigh against each other, you are in Opus 5's territory.

Choosing wrongly costs little in the first hour and a great deal by the third day, because the wrong choice stays invisible until there is something to hold the work against.

What GPT-6.1 Sol is actually built for

Sol holds the mid-high position in OpenAI's GPT-6 line, and GPT-6.1 Sol is a point update to that tier rather than a new capability level: newer weights and fixes in the same place. That matters when choosing, because you are buying a fresher version of a model whose documented strengths are complex coding, long agentic runs and multi-step technical work. Here it sits above Luna for everyday work and below Astra, which keeps the most headroom.

What a point update does not do is change the shape of the work, so do not expect a new category of answer from it. The practical consequence for a team is that a Sol setup which already runs does not have to be rewritten in order to move onto it: the same prompts, the same tools and the same structure carry over. The documented improvement is narrower than the marketing usually suggests, and the catalogue names only two areas, instruction handling and recovery after a failed step.

What Claude Opus 5 is actually built for

Opus 5 is Anthropic's frontier-tier flagship generation as listed here, and its documented strengths sit on the judging side: high-stakes analysis applied without a second pass, large-context work over long documents, codebases and transcripts, planning where constraints contradict and priorities must be chosen, and code review or debugging that would otherwise cost a person hours. Its model page is explicit that it supersedes the Opus 4.x line for new projects.

Hand it a brief where several requirements are true at once and some of them fight, and it returns a ranked answer about which are real, which are preferences and which to surrender first. Hand it the same brief as a step list and it deliberates longer than you need. Notice what that list does not contain. There is nothing about keeping a hundred tool calls alive, and nothing about throughput against a deadline, so if your brief is mainly one of those two you are reading the wrong section.

Its own catalogue entry also warns against tasks with unclear requirements, because a model willing to rank conflicting demands will rank them just as confidently when some of those demands were never real.

Where the two disagree, concretely

Take a real task: migrating a service, reviewing a contract, clearing a failing build. To Sol this is a sequence. Enumerate the call sites, change them, run the tests, report the ones still failing, retry with a narrower hypothesis. To Opus 5 the same task arrives as a set of decisions: which call sites actually matter, whether the contract obliges you on a clause you planned to ignore, whether that build failure is one bug or a design fault.

Sol completes more of the task per hour and will not, by default, tell you the plan you handed it is the wrong shape. Opus 5 will tell you that, and it will cost you time and credits while doing it. The cost of getting the pairing wrong is measurable. A Sol run pointed at the wrong problem hands back a complete, well-formatted artefact that you then have to unpick, and unpicking is slower than writing the brief again.

An Opus 5 review pointed at a mechanical problem hands back a document you have to compress into a checklist before anything can move.

Why cost per call does not decide this pair

Because the two cost about the same, the useful measure is not credits per call but credits per accepted outcome. A Sol run that finishes in one pass is cheaper than the same run abandoned halfway and restarted on Opus 5. Both are standard chat models in Text Studio drawing on one shared credit balance, the studio shows each request's cost before you send it, and switching models inside a thread costs only the difference in per-request spend. Route by behaviour first, then measure by outcome.

So keep a per-task note of how many attempts a job actually consumed, including the ones you abandoned, because that count rather than the price list is what tells you next month whether the routing was right. A single abandoned run teaches you very little; ten of them on the same kind of work give you the rule you need.

The failure mode that actually decides projects

Sol's characteristic risk is executing a wrong plan faithfully. Give it a brief built on a false premise and it carries that premise through every step with excellent discipline and no objection, because doing exactly what it was told is the behaviour you asked for. Opus 5's characteristic risk is the mirror image: it spends a long time on the framing question and, when the evidence is thin, fills the gap with prose polished enough to look resolved. One over-executes, one over-deliberates.

The mitigation for Sol is an explicit challenge clause; for Opus 5 it is an explicit step budget plus a demand that it name what is missing instead of proceeding. Both failures are cheap to catch early and expensive to catch late, and the early test is the same for either model: ask it to restate your brief in five lines and to list separately whatever it cannot verify from the material given.

A restatement that carries a false premise forward without comment is the signature of a run about to be wasted, and interrupting it at that point costs almost nothing.

How to prompt GPT-6.1 Sol so it actually checks in

Sol does not volunteer disagreement, so put the check into the prompt. Write the request as a procedure: list the requirements, have it restate them as a checklist, and flag any contradiction before it starts. Then put the challenge clause in the same sentence as the work, something to the effect that if the plan looks wrong or a requirement is impossible, stop and say so rather than continuing. Give it a stop condition too: if a step fails twice, stop and tell me what you would try next.

With those pieces its execution discipline becomes something you can supervise. Add one further clause whenever the work touches stored data: if any step would delete or overwrite something, have it describe the operation and stop for confirmation rather than proceeding. That single line turns an open-ended run into a supervised one without slowing the ordinary steps down, and it is the difference between a run you can leave alone and one you cannot.

How to prompt Claude Opus 5 so it stops deliberating

Opus 5 defaults to analysis, so your job is to bound it. Stage the request instead of asking for everything at once. State the output shape explicitly, because the model defaults to prose: a table with named columns, or an object with fixed keys, and you get something you can act on rather than something you have to parse. If you want it to execute rather than deliberate, set a step budget, define done, and ask for the decision first and the working after it, in that order.

If you want the opposite, which is usually the better use of it, ask it to rank the serious problems rather than to list everything, and to name the missing evidence before it answers. The step budget is the part people tend to skip, and it is the part that changes the result most: a budget of six steps with a named deliverable at the end turns Opus 5 from a writer of essays about your problem into something you can hand straight to the next tool.

Without it the budget is spent on framing, and the framing is rarely what you were short of.

Agentic loops, the clearest case in the whole comparison

Here the difference is least ambiguous. A loop means repeated tool calls, intermediate observations feeding the next decision, and recovery when a step returns something unexpected. That is precisely Sol's documented territory: instruction handling and recovery after a failed step are exactly what its point update improved. Opus 5 has no comparable documented emphasis here. It is not the wrong tool for a short scripted sequence; it is simply that its budget goes on judgement rather than on keeping a loop alive.

The workable division is to have Sol set out the loop's steps and run them, then bring the result to Opus 5 to judge whether the loop that came back is the loop you should have run at all. The cost of sending a loop to the wrong model shows up as an abandoned run.

Everything finished before the loop went off course has already been paid for and is then thrown away, and the retry starts from nothing, which means the second attempt also has to rebuild the context the first one had established.

Long documents and mixed-format briefs

Opus 5 is the better choice when the material is long and the conclusion must survive being read by someone else: a policy draft, a proposal, an analysis citing its evidence throughout, a contract where one missed clause has a price. Sol is the better choice when the long job is mechanical: hundreds of items under one rule, a consistent transformation across a pile, or a first pass you intend to restructure yourself. Neither defaults to structured output, so in both cases name the shape you want.

That one instruction turns a page of prose into something the next tool can consume. The tell is the shape of the input rather than its length. Many sources of one kind is volume, and volume is Sol's; several sources that disagree with each other is judgement, and judgement is Opus 5's.

Mixed-format briefs often look like the first and behave like the second, so decide which of the two you are buying before you send, because the format instruction alone will not repair a brief whose sources conflict.

For coding: split the job by stage

For reading an unfamiliar codebase, planning a change and explaining trade-offs, Sol is the natural working default and the cheaper of the two to run repeatedly. For a cause that must be traced rather than guessed, a subtle problem involving overlapping tasks or security, a review whose finding goes into a ticket, or an architecture decision you would not want to redo, Opus 5 earns its cost.

A sensible split is to draft and iterate on Sol, then send the finished diff to Opus 5 for the review that actually ships. Ask both for a diff rather than a wall of code, because the format instruction is what tells you which one you received. Ask both for the reasoning as well as the change whenever the change is not obviously correct, because one sentence on why this fix and not the neighbouring one is the cheapest available test of which model you actually got.

A diff that arrives without that sentence has told you the model wrote code, not that the model understood the defect.

Running the same prompt on both, and reading the ends

Take a task you are genuinely stuck on, write one prompt, send it to both in the same thread, and read two places rather than the conclusions. The opening tells you whether it asked the right question or accepted a vague brief, whether it followed your format constraint, and whether it flagged what it was unsure about. The tail tells you more. Watch whether the model running a long sequence began drifting on the last items, and whether the model deliberating ever actually committed to a decision.

That single test, on Ofrai, costs one extra generation and predicts more than any feature list. Run the test on the kind of task you actually do rather than on a synthetic question, and give it enough items to become long. A model that handles a three-step loop elegantly and then drifts on the twentieth item is the ordinary case rather than the exceptional one, and only a tail long enough to drift in will show you that.

When a third model beats both

Neither is right when the deciding factor is volume, latency or raw depth rather than behaviour. For summarising, rewriting, everyday drafting and bulk classification, cheaper tiers in both families do the work for a fraction of the spend: GPT-6 Luna, the GPT-5.4 Mini and Nano tiers, Claude Sonnet 5, Claude Haiku 4.5. If the task needs the hardest reasoning available rather than the most reliable execution, GPT-6 Astra is OpenAI's tier with the most headroom and sits above Sol in the same lineup.

And for very large autonomous repository changes the catalogue names a specialised option, GPT-5.3 Codex, rather than either flagship. Keep these two for work where the behaviour you need is what they are built for. The routing rule that follows is short: send the routine mass to the cheaper tier, send the hardest judgement and the longest run to these two, and leave everything in between on whatever you have already validated.

The most common mistake is not choosing wrongly between these two, but paying flagship prices for work that never needed either of them.

Ofrai credit prices

Scores are editorial estimates from in-house tests — not third-party benchmarks.

ModelKindCredits
GPT-6.1 SolChat modelInput/Output 0.365696/1.82848
Claude Opus 5Chat modelInput/Output 1.37136/6.8568

FAQ

Is GPT-6.1 Sol better than Claude Opus 5?
Neither is simply better, and price will not tell you, because the two cost about the same. The distinction is behavioural. Sol is the stronger choice for long multi-step tool-calling runs and agentic loops, where holding the procedure together and recovering from a failed step is what matters. Opus 5 is the stronger choice for conflicting requirements, long documents and conclusions someone will act on directly. The reliable way to decide is to send one real prompt to both in the same thread and read the openings and the tails.
Do I need separate OpenAI and Anthropic subscriptions to compare them?
No. Both are listed as standard chat models in Ofrai Text Studio and both draw on the same shared credit balance. Open the studio, send the same prompt to GPT-6.1 Sol and Claude Opus 5, and compare without managing two accounts, two API keys or two invoices. Cost control comes from routing each request to the model whose behaviour fits it, not from separate billing.
Which is better for long agentic or tool-calling work?
GPT-6.1 Sol. Long agentic runs with many tool calls, instruction chains that accumulate and recovery from a failed step are the documented strengths of its Sol tier, and the point update to GPT-6.1 improved instruction handling and error recovery. The caveat is that Sol will not volunteer that your plan is wrong, so put an explicit challenge clause and a stop condition into the prompt.
Which is better for long documents and conflicting requirements?
Claude Opus 5. Its documented strengths are high-stakes analysis applied without a second pass, large-context work over long documents, codebases and transcripts, and planning where constraints contradict and priorities must be chosen. If the deliverable is a document another person will read and act on, or the brief contains requirements that fight each other, that is where its cost is earned.
How do I switch between them in the middle of a task?
Switch inside the same Text Studio thread. Context and history carry across, so the expensive part of the work, everything already established about the task, is not thrown away. A workable pattern is to run the procedure on Sol, bring the result to Opus 5 to judge whether that procedure was the right one, then take it back to Sol for the remaining mechanical steps. All of it runs on one credit balance.
Is GPT-6.1 Sol the most capable OpenAI model here?
No, and it is worth being clear. GPT-6.1 Sol is a point update to the GPT-6 Sol tier, which holds a mid-high position in the GPT-6 line rather than the top. GPT-6 Luna is the everyday tier below it, and GPT-6 Astra sits above it with the most headroom on the hardest reasoning. Separately, the catalogue names GPT-5.3 Codex as the specialised option for very large autonomous repository changes. Sol is the right pick for reliable execution at its price level, not the strongest reasoning available.

Related models

Tools

Use cases